and crisp. In other words, sound can be a supporting clue, but it should not overrule better evidence.
Good use of thumping: compare several similar melons after you have already checked the field spot and rind.
Weak use of thumping: choosing the loudest or deepest-sounding melon from a mixed bin without inspecting anything else.
Red flag: a very dull, lifeless thud paired with soft areas, cracks, or a tired rind.
Best habit: treat the tap as a tie-breaker, not the main decision.
A whole watermelon beside a freshly cut red