of Illinois Extension
Do not confuse a field spot with damage. A field spot is broad, flat, and part of the rind color. It should not feel sunken, wet, cracked, or mushy. On some striped varieties the spot can look uneven around the edges, and on small personal-size watermelons it may be modest rather than huge. The color matters more than dramatic size. If two melons are similar in shape and weight, the one with the creamier yellow spot is usually the better bet.
Then Compare Weight for Size
After