And once the staircase was finished, nobody may have considered the small difference important enough to correct.
And honestly, it happens.
Homes are full of little construction imperfections that become almost invisible over the years.
A crooked trim board.
A slightly uneven floor.
A door that doesn’t quite close perfectly.
And, yes, possibly one baluster pointing the wrong way.
It May Have Been Replaced During a Repair
This is especially plausible in an older house.
Think about a staircase that has been in place for 80, 100, or even 200