years.
During that time, individual balusters can become damaged, loose, cracked, or worn.
Someone eventually needs to replace one.
The replacement might have been newly made, salvaged from another staircase, or taken from a similar section of the house. It may have had a slightly different shape—or simply been installed facing the opposite direction.
That could explain why only one baluster looks different.
The oddball may not be original to the staircase at all.
It may be a little piece of the home’s repair history.
The Staircase May Have Been